|
Methodological Approaches to L2 learning research |
|
SLA Topics SLA Bibliography Vivian Cook |
Overall problem: relationship to 'time'
i)
longitudinal (following the same learners from Time 1 to Time N)
ii) cross-sectional (taking a
sample usually of dfifferent people at Time 1, Time 2, Time N and comparing)
iii) experimental time (i.e. ultra short-term 'learning' in
experiments etc)
General
methods
the observational method
- language elicitation and analysis e.g. Hatch
the difference
method - measurement of learner or situational variables and correlation
with proficiency or something else
the manipulative method - treat one
group, not the other, measure effects of treatment
Types of
evidence
i) introspection: thinking aloud, self-observation,
grammaticality
judgements
ii) natural
data; e.g. Faerch, etc
iii) controlled data
Ethical constraints on experimenters
Designing an L2 research project ('problem decomposition')
1. Is speech more important than writing?
2. Is speech more important than writing in L2 learning?
3. Is speech more important than writing in the L2
learning of
vocabulary?
4. Is speech more important than writing in the L2
learning of English
vocabulary by French adult
learners?
5. Is speech more important than writing in the L2
learning of English
vocabulary by French adult learners
being taught in technical schools
in France?
6. Is a group of French adult learners of English in
technical schools in
France which is taught orally better
at learning vocabulary than an
otherwise identical group
that is taught through writing?
7. Are the scores on the EPVT of a group of French
adult learners of
English in technical schools in France who
are taught orally better than
an otherwise identical group that
are taught through writing?
8. Are the scores on the EPVT of a group of French
adult learners of
English in technical schools in France who
are taught orally
significantly better than an otherwise
identical group that are taught
through writing?
Amplification of this sequence will be found in Chapter 1 of V.J. Cook (ed.), Experimental Approaches to L2 Acquisition, Pergamon, 1986.
Paper on Monolingual Bias in Second Language Acquisition Research by Vivian Cook
Ayoun's paper on using web-forms as a research tool
|
|
elicited |
observational |
grammaticality |
experiments |
|
Types of data |
imitation |
data |
judgements |
|
|
grammatical morphemes |
|
|
|
|
|
communication strategies |
|
|
|
|
|
learning strategies |
|
|
|
|
|
temporal variables |
|
|
|
|
|
pro-drop |
|
|
|
|
|
acculturation |
|
|
|
|
|
variation |
|
|
|
|
|
the Competition model |
|
|
|
|
|
head-direction |
|
|
|
|
|
motivation |
|
|
|
Links to SLA methods/questionnaires etc
Mean Length of
Utterance
Cook's
Consonant Test
Motivation
test