Thrush and anvil 01.06.2002

 

           

 

 

    Ó Robert Burton

Song thrushes are famous for eating snails. They bash the shells against a stone (marked with a red line above) and extract the battered and bruised body of the poor snail. But are they really a ‘gardener’s friend’ for keeping these pests at bay? I pondered this when I found a thrush’s anvil while working in the garden. The anvil was only a 2-inch pebble but it was surrounded by the broken remains of a dozen shells, mostly of the banded snail but one of a large garden snail.

A dozen snails is nothing compared to the numbers I find crawling over my patio after dark or hiding under flowerpots and piles of bricks. The truth is that thrushes eat snails mostly during two periods in the year: in mid-summer and late winter. This is when other animal foods can be in short supply because they are sheltering from drought or hidden by snow. A snail’s shell is not a complete protection but it is much more economical for a thrush to gobble a caterpillar or worm than to go through the palaver of carrying a snail to an anvil, laboriously smashing the shell and extracting the contents. Snails can be regarded as a form of emergency ration.

For this reason, I cannot imagine that the two pairs of thrushes that frequent my garden have any impact on the numbers of snails. The moral is that it is dangerous to conclude that the presence of a predator necessarily has a serious effect on its prey.  This works both ways. Song thrushes are thriving in my garden despite regular visits from magpies, crows, jays, cats and sparrowhawks.

©Robert Burton 2002

Top of Page