|
What's New:
July
2008
01/07/08: A few months ago I mentioned a book that was soon to be published,
The Liberal Defence of Murder (Verso Books, 2008). Well it has now appeared,
and I can whole-heartedly recommend it.
This is
from the
publishers web site:
"Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, a number
of prominent thinkers on the Left found themselves increasingly aligned with
their ideological opposites. Over the last decade, many of these thinkers have
become close to Washington; forceful supporters of the War on Terror, they help
frame arguments for policymakers and provide the moral and intellectual
justification for Western military intervention across the globe. From Kanan
Makiya, one of the chief architects of the US invasion and occupation of Iraq,
to Bernard Henri-Levy’s advocacy of “humanitarian” intervention, The Liberal
Defense of Murder traces the journey of these figures from left to right
and explores their critical role in the creation of the new American empire.
With wide-ranging testimony from many key figures on the left, this is a crucial
account of the emergence of the “pro-war left,” and its shaping of our post-9/11
world.
Richard Seymour lives and writes in
London. His website
Lenin’s Tomb comments on
issues such as imperialism, Zionism, Islamophobia and anti-capitalism, and
covers strikes and protests with footage, images and reportage. It has been
cited in, among others, Private Eye, the Guardian and
Slate. This is Richard Seymour’s first book."
June
2008
29/06/08: I have just re-written Essay Twelve
Part One
-- Dialectics And Metaphysics. I have corrected several errors, clarified the
argument and added some new material. It is now about 5% longer.
23/06/08: The Summary of Essay Twelve Part One --
The Metaphysical Status Of Dialectics --
has just been published.
16/06/08: I have just re-written Essay Nine
Part Two
-- The Damage 'Materialist Dialectics' Has Inflicted On Marxism --,
correcting several mistakes and typos; I have also added about 3500 words of new
material.
06/06/08: I have just re-written essay Eight Part Three
"What
are 'Dialectical Contradictions'", correcting several errors and
infelicities, adding new material. It is now just over 10% longer.
May
2008
30/05/08: I have just added 1500 words of comment and argument to Note 4 of
Essay Seven Part
One, in view of the fact that my original argument had a few gaping
holes in it.
I have
also added new links to
this page, which records the many 'debates' I
have had on the Internet with dialecticians (mostly at RevLeft).
25/05/08: I have re-posted, as a separate Essay (i.e., as
08-03 -- "What
are 'Dialectical Contradictions'"), a long footnote that
appeared in Essay Eight
Part Two.
Because of its length, this footnote has in fact taken on a life of
its own. Buried
as it was in 08-02, it was not easy to access.
25/05/08: I have now published the Summary of Essay Eleven
Part One: "The 'Totality' -- WTF Is It?"
---oOo---
I have
been away for over three weeks, hence the lack of activity at this site.
The
next work to be published will be a summary of Essay Eleven Part One; that will
be followed sometime in July by Essay Thirteen Part Three: "Dialectics,
Language, 'Mind' and 'Cognition'".
April
2008
26/04/08: I am progressively re-writing
Essay
Sixteen, which is an extended summary of my ideas. Because of its
length, it has been broken up into manageable sections, each corresponding
more-or-less to one of the main Essays.
To that
end, I have just finished the summary of Essay Ten
Part One: Dialectics -- Refuted By History.
24/04/08: Because of the interest it is receiving (in fact it is currently the
most visited page at this site), I have just re-written Essay Ten
Part One,
making numerous small changes and correcting a few errors and typos.
23/04/08: Essay One has
just be re-written. This Essay explains the background to my work, and serves as
an Introduction.
21/04/08: The re-write of Essay Thirteen
Part One
(on Lenin's Materialism and Empirio-criticism) has just been completed.
I have
corrected several errors and typos and added about 3500 words of new material.
17/04/08: I have just re-written
Essay Five, since it is still attracting much
interest.
I have
corrected a few errors and typos, made the argument clearer and added small
amounts of new material.
It is
now just short of 5% longer.
I am
also in the process of re-writing Essay Thirteen
Part One,
posting the changes as they are being made.
March
2008 Latest
31/03/08: The summary of Essay Nine
Part Two has just been published -- 'Militants
on Methadone'.
This
outlines the reasons why I think dialecticians have swallowed this ruling-class
theory, and the consequent damage this has done to Marxism.
27/03/08: I have now written and posted a summary of Essay Nine
Part One: 'Dialectics -- A Ruling-Class Theory'.
24/03/08: I have just written the
Summary of Essay Eight Part Two -- Why
'Dialectical Contradictions' cannot be equated with opposing forces.
20/03/08: Over the last few months I have been completely re-writing Essay
Sixteen (which is an extended introduction to and summary of my work), breaking it up into
manageable parts.
Well,
as part of that, I
have now written the
Summary to Essay Eight Part One.
18/03/08: I have just re-written Essay Twelve
Part One,
correcting several errors, and adding new material. I have also tried to make
the argument even clearer.
That
Essay is now approx 3,500 words longer.
17/03/08: Visitors can find my pictures of the recent anti-war demonstration in
London,
here.
07/03/08: I have just finished re-writing
Essay Five
-- 'Motion is not Contradictory' -- making numerous small changes, correcting
several errors and typos, and adding some new material. It is now about 1000
words longer.
05/03/08: A few weeks ago, a sympathetic reader of my Essays added a comment
about my work to the article on DM at Wikipedia.
Unfortunately, a rather miffed Maoist and a thin-skinned Trotskyist deleted it
(the latter after it had been restored).
Apparently, such 'scientific' comrades cannot tolerate the idea that their
theory has been systematically demolished, and think that censoring me will make
me or my ideas go away.
However, the original poster has restored it again. You can read it
here (if it is still there!).
[It can
be accessed in the History section of that article anyway.]
04/03/08: The seminar in Oxford went well. I filmed the talk and subsequent
discussion, but the lighting was poor. If I can improve the quality of the video
on edit, I'll post it on YouTube.
I'll
also post a transcript of the talk, and discussion at a later date.
February
2008
28/02/08: Essay Nine
Part Two has just been re-written; I have
corrected a few errors, clarified the argument somewhat and added new material.
It is now just under 2000 words longer.
Essay Five
is still being re-written
Also, I
have just received the second edition of Reason In Revolt by Woods and
Grant.
The
chapter on logic is still among the worst I have ever seen in a book about
dialectics, even though, at my suggestion, Alan Woods has removed the syntactic
mess that used to appear on page 98.
The
book still makes grossly erroneous remarks about
Wittgenstein (among others), and it repeats all the old errors
(debunked at this site) as if they were eternal truths.
On page
101, the authors still manage to get George Boole's name wrong (they call him 'George
Boyle') even though I pointed this error out to Woods in 2004 -- just as they
mis-spell Gottlob Frege's name on the same page.
These
might seem small errors, but they reveal how sloppy dialecticians are when it
comes to logic -- even after such things have been pointed out to them!
[There
are plenty
more examples of this sort of thing
here.]
25/02/08: I have just received a copy of
Science, Marxism and the Big Bang,
by Peter Mason. While this book is a short critique of Woods and Grant's
Reason in Revolt, it is by far and away the most measured and reasonable
defence I have ever seen of Dialectical Materialism. I will add a few comments
about this book to Essay Seven at a later date.
Added later: I wrote the above after reading only half of the said
book. However, much of the second half is highly repetitive, the author becoming
fixated on infinity, saying more or less the same thing over and over again for
the next 60 pages!
I am
also in the process of re-writing
Essay Five in view
of the fact that it is attracting quite a lot of attention right now.
21/02/08: I have just re-written
Essay One, correcting several errors, and
adding new material. It is now about 5% longer.
14/02/08: A few months ago, I wrote a very basic outline of the egregious
logical errors Hegel committed, which launched the 'dialectic', and which
subsequent prominent Marxists accepted uncritically.
I have now
re-written it to make the argument even
clearer.
It was
originally designed for those who found the extended argument
here,
here,
here
and
here a
little too daunting.
That
being so, the dialectic has no foundation in logic, or in fact.
It is
no surprise therefore to find it has presided over 150 years of almost total
failure.
12/02/08: After a long delay, I have finally published Essay Thirteen Part One:
Lenin's
Disappearing Definition Of Matter.
This
Essay took me far longer to complete than I had imagined!
01/02/08: The next Essay to be published will be ready to post in the next week
or so. It is Essay Thirteen Part One, which will demolish what is easily Lenin's
worst published work: the lamentable Materialism and Empirio-Criticism.
Apologies for the delay, but it has been far harder to finalise than I had
anticipated.
A
supporter of this site will be addressing a conference on the renewal of the
left, to be held at Oxford University at the end of February.
More
details
here.
|
