P AI S N E R&co
Bouvrie House
154 Fleet Street
London EC4A 2DO
Telephone 0171.353 0299
Direct Line Q 171-42 7 13 ] 7
Entail paisner@patsner.co.uk
Fax 0 171-593 8621
DX 198
Date 26 November 1998
Dear Sir
YOURSELF -V- (1) INTERCOLLEGIATE BOARD IN ORTHOPAEDIC SURGERY AND (2).ICHST
Further to the Tribunal's Direction on 27 August, we attach a list of names, and should be obliged if you would acknowledge safe receipt,
The names shown for the years 1989 to 1994 are those who were enrolled by the Specialist Advisory Committee in Orthopaedics Surgery as Senior Registrars in those years.
The list for 1995 is a list of names which appear to have been enrolled either as Senior Registrars or Career Registrars in that year. As we have previously explained, our clients do not keep historic lists, and it has been necessary for them to spend a considerable amount of time compiling this list from the Minute Books of the Specialist Advisory Committee. It would appear that there is a certain amount of duplication, but there is unfortunately no way of cross-checking the list without an excessive amount of work. Our clients cannot be certain that every name on the enclosed list was in fact enrolled in 1995 or that other trainees who are not on the enclosed list were not enrolled. The fact that a trainee was enrolled in a particular year does not mean that he or she was appointed to a post in that year- Enrolment was a consequence of appointment, not a precondition for appointment, and it was quite common for a trainee to be appointed to a Senior Registrar or Career Registrar post and not then enrol with the SAC for some time, or at all. Indeed, as you are aware, it was perfectly possible to obtain a consultant's post without ever having been enrolled or accredited.
In short, the attached list is not a comprehensive or accurate record of all those in training as Registrars and Senior Registrars between 1989 and 1995. Our clients do not accept that it has any relevance to your complaint in any event.
Names of Trainees enrolled for Higher Surgical Training
by the Specialist Advisory Committee in
Orthopaedic Surgery 1989-1995
1989-1994 Senior Registrars
1995 Senior Registrars and Career Registrars
1989(31). Mr R J Crawford
Mr J C Kaye
Mr S P Frostick
Mr A Hamilton
Mr J G Brown
Mr P J Gill
Mr C Ogilvie
Mr H P J Walsh
Mr M G Matthews
Mr C Rand
Mr R G Wetherell
Mr A Stirrat
Mr H E Ware
Mr A H Waterfield
Mr J H Jessop
Mr A A Henderson
Mr P W Howard
Mr I Hudson
Mr J G Mackinnon
Mr J G B MacLean
Mr G A Pryor
Mr J W Rosson
Mr J S Wand
Mr D S Barrett
Mr R J Barr
Mr N C Bayliss
Mr P Laing
Mr R Helm
Mr S J McLoughlin
Mr J B Williamson
Mr C Schofield
1990 (58): Mr P R Kay
Mr I J Brenkel
Mr S R Bollen
Mr F R Howell
Mr J R Buckley
Mr J D Hutchison
Mr P Keogh
Mr J G O'Beirne
Mr J J O'Flanagan
Mr M E O'Sullivan
Mr G Scott
Mr P J Sell
Mr G H H Broome
Mr J M Leitch
Mr J G Andrew
Mr N J S Kehoe
Mr S J Shaw
Mr S M Turner
Mr A R Beaumont
Mr S R Carter
Mr G N Fernandez
Mr W M Harper
Mr C B D Lavy
Mr G G MeLeod
Mr E F Wheelwright
Mr S H White
Mr G J Belham
Ms A B Ashbrooke
Mr A J Carr
Mr J J Dias
Mr J K Dowell
Mr M J P Fordyce
Mr B S Goldie
Mr M Goodwin
Mr W M Ledingham
Mr D J Knight
Mr F McGoldrick
Mr D A MacDonald
Mr S J E Matthews
D R Bickerstaff
D P W O'Doherty
B D Todd
A S Bryan
E R Gardner
G R Tait
M E Walsh
S P Cavanagh
M C Flannery
G P Graham
H C Hoddinoh
C J Hindley
B H Pennie
M Porteous
P D Triffit
A H R W Simpson
P A Butler-Manuel
1991 (50): P J Radford
M W Jones
M A P Bransby-Zachary
R N S Slater
A V Bonniici
R S Turner
A D North
P A Butler-Manuel
M F S Taylor
A H Richards
H J Clarke
R G Hackney
T F Sibly
S H Bridle
R S Twyman
M Thomas
D Yanni
E J Parnell
Ms D M Eastwood
A J Ward
N W Valentine
R W Parkinson
S P Hodgson
R R Ingram
M G Hullin
J F Keating
S A Henderson
M Kurer
P G Sherry
M D Loeffler
G E B Giddins
D W Murray
J L Fowler
P Roberts
J R Wootton
A D Clayson
C Dent
D Pemberton
M V S Maheson
I N Mawhinney
P J Briggs
D Conlan
A P Roberts
Miss C G Brignall
R J H Gregory
D I Wise
R Eckersley
A G Davies
J R Wootton
L G H Jacobs
1992 (74): J P Martindale
Q G N Cox
Miss A Rees
R Field
S J Moyes
D S Elliot
R Gundle
D Gale
R Marks
Major M P M Stewart
J D S McCutchan
J P Martindale
R S Majowski
Ms A Rees
B Cohen
A Doran
D J Edwards
W W Williams
P J Livesey
H Noordeen
W J P Radford
P Gibb
R Gundle
S G Royle
R M Tillman
R S Jeffery
H G David
G P Ashcroft
S U Siolin
M D Laverick
M J Bryant
P Maginn
J P McCabe
I R Scott
B Cohen
A Doran
R D A Dodds
R A Power
M A Churchill
M J Curtis
M S B E cammell
N C Neal
C P Kelly
C R Walker
I A Harvey
S G Royle
A S Paul
D M Lang
Ms P S Costigan
M J Bryant.
P Maginn
G K Barry
A M Nanu
P R Stuart
R C Handley
A T Recce
S Lambert
G D J Marsh
M J Curtis
M A C Craigen
J Field
M F Pearse
R B C Treacy
P J Ratcliffe
D J McBride
H Casserly
H G David
D P Newington
R Burnett
S U Sjolin
D E Hynes
W A Curtin
J P Corrigan
T J O'Sullivan
1993 (75): D N Kreibich
P A Millner
P J Warren
Ms A L Hulme
J Nolan
D B Singh
M T Proctor
J P G Targett
I M Nugent
J E C Benfield
K J O'Dwyer
S P Michael
E S Isbister
N R Gillham
J L Barrie
D J Shrewing
P M Alderman
D Chan
N Maffuli
S C Montgomery
N S Simpson
H E Potts
D A D Calthorpe
A J Forester
D L Shaw
B W Scott
G C Foubister
A M Clarke
K S Eyres
D A A Archibald
B R D P Bradnock
J P Ivory
N R Boeree
S J Krikier
P R Glithero
D Griffiths
D D Robinson
N W Kenny
S D Fewster
A J Timperley
L Wilson
P G Chapman
J P Compson
M S Pearce
Ms K E Daly
J K O'Dowd
G J Stranks
S J Hughes
S J Gregg-Smith
M F Gargan
V G Langkamer
K S K Cheah
M J Jane
D J Bamford
R A Harvey
F P Monsell
B A Clift
K M Bell
I A C Lennox
E L Masterson
J M O'Byrne
P Murray
Major M B F Eskander
D L Limb
G H Anderson
D A Ward
M C P Wilkinson
J P Murphy
E D Fern
C W Oliver
J St J M Dwyer
R Spencer Jones
S Dhar
P D Marshall
P Murray
1994(76). T D Owen
D L Limb
M Needoff
J B Hunter
H V Parmar,
A Fairbank
G R Kerr
L T S W Muir
P J James
K S Baird
D J McCormack
P Campbell
J M Rowles
P L Sanderson
T Green
G J S C Taylor
H R Chissell
S C Evans
M F Brown
K M Desai
N I Garlick
M Moss
T E J Hems
G J Charnley
J H Marshall
A Mohammed
A J Johnstone
M M Orr
D K Asante
A P Cosgrove
R M Nicholas
I S Corry
D C Borton
D M Cogley
C Natali
Mr N C Birch
Mr D M Hahn
Mr S F Journeaux
D J Rossouw
S J Barnes
S P Bendall
M Bishay
N Blewitt
C Brooks
D M Cogley
D Cox
R D D Duncan
M J Flowers
A J Gibbon
C L M H Gibbons
R Gibson
R M Gillies
M Grevitt
A Hashemi-Nejad
S M Hay
S M G Jones
W J Leach
M L Newey
K J H Newman
D A O'Farrell
J M Pike
C M Robinson
P P Sarangi
A M Williams
G J Packer
J P Holland
G R Taylor
P C Shewell
J A F Buchanan
A J Grant
R L Williams
P J Parker
T K Karr
V J Woolf
C A Wilson
I Wallace
1995(338?) J Sinha
D S Marks
D M Ricketts
I Chakrabarti
M McNally
C M Andrews
I Braithwaite
J Bruguera
D A Campbell
J L Kitson
A Mohsen
J Oni
M L Rawes
D J Weir
U G Fazzi
P C Nolan
C R P Williams
P J A Cox
Ms C M Duffy
A J Unwin
A L Armstrong
R S Bale
I W Barlow
P R Davies
A Day
A J R Gray
A Gregori
E M Holt
P L Housden
A Iossifidis
G S Keene
G M Lawson
H Lyall
R A Marston
H A Maxwell
J S Moir
B Okafor
P J O'Rouke
T J Peckham
S Roberts
C J Shaw
D I S Sweetnam
J Du Fosse
N Shaw
P F Partington
P D Birdsall
A M Port
K P Emmerson
R Short
J C Coorsh
S Mohammad
S J Calder
N Tulwa
P Templeton
D Shardlow
H R Williams
A Jennings
D J Ellis
L Irwin
A Furlong
N Hyder
M Farrar
J N S Davison
Mrs I Dunn
A W McCaskie
C Heral-Palou
N Bradbury
G Geutjens
P Brownson
D I Clark
R H Hartley
J Chell
D McDermott
N D Downing
S M Hay
J Brown
R Kerry
A J Hamer
A C Howard
P R M Black
A S Vince
M Bowditch
F H Norman-Taylor
Griffen
Hobby
J D Goodall
M S Davies
J M R Burwell
R J Sinnerton
W J Harries
Ms N S Kendall
G C Singer
D Hargreaves
M R Hamlet
M J Barry
D R M Redfern
R Thomas
D Calder
A Chakrabati
P L S Li
I McNabb
S K Tucker
D Moore
D Goodier
G Robbins
C Hatrick
S Mannion
M Cornell
K Srnith
J F Lucas
R M Pattison
H Apthorp
J P Walczak
J E Nicholl
S Hutchinson
Ms S L Phillips
Zahn
Smart
R G Nfiddleton
N Shergill
S Kumar
F Hadad
J J Manktelow
J Jeffrey
J W Tice
J S Bell
V R Patel
G P Paremain
A Sakellariou
N Price
J G Hussell
S Palmer
A S Rai
D O'Connor
J J Southgate
M G Uglow
P Bagnall
N Flynn
Ramos
J R Williams
D A Wallace
M Wood
M Emerton
M J Ashworth
Ms V B L Conboy
Ms P Allen
A Weale
P Kerr
A J Kelly
A B Dunkley
B J C Freeman
A Feldman
J Wilson
R Dodenhoff
P J Gibbons
M T Taylor
M A Green
H J Fox
J M Hopper
P J Shaylor
J M Latham
R L Morgan Jones
P A Gregson
M J Hutchinson
S C Tandon
R Spencer-Jones
Chan
M S Hennessy
A Bass
N J Donnachie
S N Radcliffe
M E Lovell
Barton-Harison
B Rhodes
S Alleock
S H Bostock
S G Collier
R P Goel
T Lawrence
P J Mobbs
N S Qureshi
W G Ryan
A Sinha
D H Sochart
Ms D Bramley
Ms G Ferrier
C R C Walker
J G Warner
E R Jago
D O'Donoghue
N Kurdy
M C B Webber
M Giddens
R P O Rice
A Shenolikar
D Woodnut
R Williams
M Holt
N Giles
A W John
Ms S Burgert
H Richards
Ms K Lewis
N Evans
T W Dougall
G Keenan
A Baker
P M Williams
P D Henman
P Rickhuss
Kelly
Ms J McMillan
G M Mackay
R A Dunsmuir
C H Gerrand
Ms J McEachan
C M Guthrie
M P Kelly
Abushaala
Ms J McBirnie
I McLean
P Loxdale
I D Sargeant
G W Bowyer
J Hull
A Jennings
J Chell
D McDermott
Hopkinson-Wolley
J L Hobby
F Nortnan-Taylor
S Mannion.
P J Halliwell
R W Walker
P J Ward
A S RAi
M G Uglow
MS S Phillips
D Woods
Ms V B L Conboy
Taylor
Shaylor
R A Raine
P Cool
G M Graham
N Steele
Ms G Ferrier
D Woodmitt
H Richards
S R Murali
A Sutherland
G Keenan
A R Baker
J P Bidwell
M J G Blyth
T P S Bhullar
P M Binfield
C E Bruce
T Bull
Miss S M Caiach
A C W Campbell
T Dougall
S C Ellis
C N A Esler
M Foxworthy
J G Gardiner
J R W Hardy
G D Harper
ACWHui
M Jackson
J R Lavelle
A R Lyons
Ms J M MeBirnic
B J McElroy
S Nayagam
A P Phillipson
A H N Robinson
Surgeon Lieutenant Commander Howell
M J Ashworth
J P Cooper
S Deo
G Holt
E R Jago
S J Palmer
S L Royston
J Chitnavis
Miss N Davis
D J Dunlop
S Jari
D S Johnson
D E Porter
M C B Webber
P F Partington
A C Howard.
J D Goodall
D A Wallace
W J Harries
P S S Kerr
J M Hopper
J M Latham
R A Barnes
R A Wilkes
N H Courtman
M E Lovell
S G Rao
J G Warner
D Teanby
W G Ryan
N Kurdy
S H Bostock
Ms S Burgert
A Irwin
W P M Gough
Major A W Kent
B S O'Brien
A R Lyons
D J Gidden
R A Duthie
P A Templeton
A W McCaskie
G G Geutjems
N Bradbury
P Brownson
R J Sinnerton
G C Singer
S Godsiff
A Chakrabarti
V R Patel
M Edwards
D A Woods
A E Weale
D J Johnstone
A S Lee
P J Mobbs
D J Pegg
A P Maskell
M D Holt
P Rickhuss
PA IS N E R & CO
Yours sincerely
PAISNER & CO