Welfare Reform

If a free society cannot help the many who are poor, it cannot save the few who are rich.  

Contemporary stuff:

Information about the system we have now is on a separate page.

Benefits - policy journal

New Tax Credits consultation document

Benefits for people living abroad

House of Commons Social Security Committee

The Social Security Advisory Committee

The Welfare Reform and Pensions Bill 1999, explanatory notes about the bill and information from DSS about the intentions behind it. The main controversy has been about Incapacity Benefit where it seems that the proposals are directly contrary to the stated aim of encouraging people to make their own provision and to give security to people who cannot work.

Polly Toynbee: How serious is the Government about redistribution, poverty and social exclusion?

HM Treasury site

Government welfare reform

Joseph Rowntree Foundation: Important source of research on benefits, poverty and related topics

Labour Left Briefing

Citizen's Income

Means testing sounds a good idea doesn't it. Give the help to the people who need it most.

But when you look at the problems Tony Blair is complaining about, apart from spending going up, most of them are related to people being trapped on benefits and the effect that has on incentives. Journalists are so far removed from the world of the poor that they don't know the rules. And as long as we have means testing no one will pay for their own insurance or pension unless they are pretty confident that they will never be poor enough to pass the means test or, like most poorer people, they don't understand how the system works

Personally I think the Beveridge Plan is the only one which works. Make everyone pay something identifiable so that when they come to claim they don't feel any guilt. Make sure that everyone is in the same system so that people can't be stigmatised. Avoid means testing as much as possible so that people have an incentive to make their own provision if they can afford it.

Benefits which are reserved for the poor will end up like the workhouse: oppressive and intimidating to ensure that only those with no alternative will be reduced to claiming.

Historical stuff:

History of the American Social Security System

Speeches at the 33rd anniversary of (US) Social Security ceremonies

Poor Relief

The Poor Law

PRIVATE CHARITY AND THE 1834 POOR LAW

Five Hundred Years of English Poor Laws, 1349-1834: Regulating the Working and Nonworking Poor

Social Security and Social Work

Milestones in Rating history

Beveridge Report

Poor Laws

Text of the 1601 Poor Law

The best history of the Welfare State I've found is Nicholas Timmins - The Five Giants. I have only found a review in German, but on the same site you can find some material about the German Social security system.

And did you know that the magazine which today is The Health Service Journal, first appeared in 1892 as The Poor Law Officers' Journal?

Last updated August 28, 2007

Weasel Words