Alt+left-arrow to return from a link
Docketed: 05/31/2007
Termed: 03/27/2009
Nature of Suit: 2890 Other Statutory Actions
Appeal From: United States District Court for the District of Columbia
Originating Court Information:
District: 0090-1 : 01cv00731 lead: 01cv00731
Trial Judge: Richard W. Roberts, U.S. District Judge
Date Filed: 04/04/01
Date order/judgment: 03/28/07
Date NoA filed: 05/25/07
Fee status: paid
Prior cases: None
Current cases: None
Panel Assignment:
Date of Hearing: 04/07/2008
Date of Decision: 03/27/2009
Date Completed: 03/27/2009
| Plaintiff-Appellant | Represented by |
| El-Shifa Pharmaceutical Industries Company
Plaintiff-Appellant |
Stephen J. Brogan
[COR LD NTC Retained Atty] Timothy John Finn Direct: 202-879-3789 [COR Retained Atty] Katherine Eugenia Stern Direct: 202-879-3842 [COR Retained Atty] Christian G. Vergonis Direct: 202-879-3914 [COR Retained Atty] Jones Day Firm: 202-879-3939 51 Louisiana Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20001-2113 |
| Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris,
Plaintiff-Appellant |
Stephen J. Brogan
[COR LD NTC Retained Atty] (see above) Timothy John Finn Direct: 202-879-3789 [COR Retained Atty] (see above) Katherine Eugenia Stern Direct: 202-879-3842 [COR Retained Atty] (see above) Christian G. Vergonis Direct: 202-879-3914 [COR Retained Atty] (see above) |
v. |
| Defendant-Appellee | Represented by |
| United States of America
Defendant-Appellee |
Dana J. Martin
Direct: 202-514-5377 [COR LD NTC Gvt Atty US Agency] U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Civil Division Appellate Staff Room 7246 950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20530-0001 C. Frederick Beckner, III Direct: 202-514-3045 [COR Gvt Atty US Agency] U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Office of the Attorney General Room 3129 Firm: 202-514-2001 950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20530 Jeffrey S. Bucholtz [COR Gvt Atty US Agency] King & Spalding LLP Firm: 202-737-0500 1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Suite 200 Washington, DC 20006-4706 Mark B. Stern [COR Gvt Atty US Agency] U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Civil Division Appellate Staff 950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20530-0001 Jeffrey Allen Taylor, U.S. Attorney [COR Gvt Atty US Agency] U.S. Attorney's Office (USA) Civil Appellate Firm: 202-514-7159 555 4th Street, NW Washington, DC 20530 |
El-Shifa Pharmaceutical Industries Company; Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris,
Plaintiffs-Appellants
v.
United States of America,
Defendant-Appellee
| Date | # | Docket Entry |
| 05/31/2007 | {1} | Civil-US Case docketed. Notice of Appeal filed by Appellant El-Shifa Pharm, Appellant Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris. [1044224-1] (lvs) |
| 06/01/2007 | {2} | Clerk’s Order filed [1044236]:
Directing Appellant to file [1044236-1]: docketing statement due 7/2/07 for El-Shifa Pharm; certificate of counsel due 7/2/07 for El-Shifa Pharm; statement of issues due 7/2/07 for El-Shifa Pharm; any procedural motions due 7/2/07 for El-Shifa Pharm; transcript status notice due 7/2/07 for El-Shifa Pharm; deferred appendix notice due 7/2/07 for El-Shifa Pharm; appearance form due 7/2/07 for Timothy John Finn; any dispositive motions due 7/16/07 for El-Shifa Pharm. Directing Appellee to file [1044236-2]: certificate of counsel due 7/2/07 for USA; any procedural motions due 7/2/07 for USA; appearance form due 7/2/07 for R. Craig Lawrence; any dispositive motions due 7/16/07 for USA. [Entry Date: 6/1/07] |
| 07/02/2007 | {3} | Notice filed by Appellants El-Shifa Pharm and Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris Final transcript status notice filed [1052416-1]. No transcripts are necessary for this appeal as the case was decided on the pleadings. Certificate of mail service date 7/2/07. |
| 07/02/2007 | {4} | Initial Submissions filed by Appellant El-Shifa Pharm, Appellant Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris [1052425-1]: docketing statement; certificate of counsel; statement of issues; and deferred appendix notice (Deferred Appendix needed = n). |
| 07/02/2007 | {5} | Entry of Appearance filed by Attorneys Stephen J. Brogan and Timothy John Finn for Appellants Salah El Din Ahmed Idris and El-Shifa Pharm [1052426-1]. |
| 07/02/2007 | {6} | Statement filed by Appellant El-Shifa Pharm, Appellant Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris pursuant to FRAP 26.1 providing corporate disclosure listing [1052430-1]. Certificate of Mail Service date 7/2/07. |
| 07/24/2007 | {7} | Entry of Appearance filed by Attorney C. Frederick Beckner for Appellee USA, Mark B. Stern for Appellee USA, Dana J. Martin for Appellee USA [1055861-1]. |
| 07/24/2007 | {8} | Initial Submissions filed by Appellee USA [1055867-1]: certificate of counsel. |
| 10/19/2007 | {9} | Clerk's Order filed [1074569] establishing the initial briefing schedule [1074569-1]: Appellant's brief due on 12/4/07; Appellant's appendix due on 12/4/07; Appellee's brief due on 1/3/08; Appellant's reply brief due on 1/17/08; [Entry Date: 10/19/07] |
| 11/20/2007 | {10} | Motion filed (5 copies) by Appellant El-Shifa Pharm (certificate of mail service dated 11/20/07) to extend time to file [1081941-1] briefs [1074569-1]. |
| 11/26/2007 | {11} | Clerk's Order filed [1082052] granting motion extend time filed by El-Shifa Pharm [1081941-1]; Revising the briefing schedule as follows: [1074569-1] Appellant's brief due on 1/18/08; Appellant's appendix due on 1/18/08; Appellee's brief due on 2/19/08; Appellant's reply brief due on 3/3/08 [Entry Date: 11/26/07] |
| 01/18/2008 | {12} | Brief filed by Appellant El-Shifa Pharm, Appellant Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris [1095014-1]. Copies: 15. Certificate of service date 1/18/08. |
| 01/18/2008 | {13} | Appendix filed by Appellant El-Shifa Pharm, Appellant Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris [1095022-1]. Copies: 10. Certificate of service date 1/18/08. |
| 02/04/2008 | {14} | Clerk's Order filed [1096899] to schedule oral argument [1096899-1] before Judge Initials: DHG KLH TBG on 4/7/08 at 9:30 AM. [Entry Date: 2/4/08] |
| 02/21/2008 | {15} | Brief filed by Appellee USA [1100824-1]. Copies: 15. Certificate of mail service date 2/19/08. |
| 03/03/2008 | {16} | Reply Brief lodged by Appellant El-Shifa Pharm, Appellant Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris [1102683-1]. Copies: 15. Certificate of service date 3/3/08, by mail. |
| 03/04/2008 | {17} | Corrected Reply Brief filed by Appellant El-Shifa Pharm, Appellant Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris [1103174-1]. Copies: 15. Certificate of service date 3/4/08, by mail. |
| 03/31/2008 | {18} | Per Curiam Order filed [1108402] allocating oral argument time as follows: Appellant -- 15 Minutes, Appellee -- 15 Minutes. One counsel per side to argue; directing party to file Form 72 notice of arguing attorney - due 04/03/2008 [07-5174] |
| 03/31/2008 | {19} | Form from Arguing Attorney - - 2. Arguing Person Information Updated for: Christian G. Vergonis arguing for Appellants El-Shifa Pharmaceutical Industries Company and Salah El Din Ahmed Mohammed Idris [07-5174] |
| 03/31/2008 | {20} | Form from Arguing Attorney - - Arguing Person Information Updated for: C. Frederick Beckner, III arguing for Appellee United States of America [07-5174] |
| 04/07/2008 | {21} | Oral Argument Held before Judge Ginsburg, Henderson and Griffith [07-5174] |
| 04/18/2008 | {22} | Transcript [1111902] of oral argument [07-5174] |
| 03/27/2009 | {23} | Per Curiam Judgment filed [1172575] that the judgment of the district court appealed from in this cause is hereby affirmed for the reasons in the accompanying opinion. Judge Ginsburg, Henderson and Griffith [07-5174] |
| 03/27/2009 | {24} | Opinion filed [1172578] (Pages: 12) for the Court by Judge Griffith; Concurring/Dissenting Opinion (Pages: 14) by Judge Ginsburg [07-5174] {98.2kb.pdf, source} |
| 03/27/2009 | {25} | Clerk's Order filed [1172580] withholding issuance of the mandate. [07-5174] |
| PACER Service Center | |||
| Transaction Receipt | |||
| 03/29/2009 15:28:59 | |||
| PACER Login: | CJHjr | Client Code: | El-Shifa |
| Description: | Docket | Case Number: | 07-5174 |
| Billable Pages: | 2 | Cost: | 0.16 |
Source: https://ecf.cadc.uscourts.gov/ (CM/ECF: Case Management-Electronic Case Files) (WebPACER: “Public Access to Court Electronic Records,” U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit). The papers in this case are not available online from the Court, except (with a PACER account) where denoted by a link in the docket number column. A photocopy is available from the Clerk’s office.
By CJHjr: Formatted (xhtml/css), bold-face, links, text {in braces}, highlighting.
This document is not copyrighted and may be freely copied.
CJHjrCharles Judson Harwood Jr.
Posted March 20 2008. Updated May 8 2009.
http://homepage.ntlworld.com/jksonc/docs/el-shifa-docket-cadc-07-5174.html
Visitors (all pages, from Feb. 10 2008):
