Here are some of this book's reviews
This fun outing has three things going for it: the story, the writing, and the art - a triple threat in the picture-book department.
The rhymed narrative is cheerful, telling the cumulative tale of a kite that keeps going skyward, taking Dad and a host of others-including a postman, a bank robber, ". . . a policeman riding on a horse, a bridegroom (and his bride, of course)," even a rhinoceros, a tiger, and a kangaroo go up for a surprise ride when they grab the string. Young Sam keeps pleading - "Can I hold it now? . . . I'm old enough -I know I am!" But the refrain is refrained: "No, you're too small! . . . This kite needs someone bigger." When Sam finally gets his hands on the string, he pulls them all back to terra firma. No tricks, just so - "I'm not too small, and as you see, this kite needs someone just like me!"
Bravo, Sam, and a decided nod to Reynolds's art, too, with its buoyant, serene tomfoolery full of round-mouthed, dot-eyed whimsy. (Picture book. 3-6)
KIRKUS REVIEWS
In Emmett's winning fable about competence and confidence, young Sam believes he's old enough to take the reins of his new kite, which Reynolds depicts as larger, than the young hero (and nearly as large as Dad). "No, you're too small!" says Dad. "This kite needs someone bigger." Then the wind kicks up and the father finds himself flying. Several other adults ("a postman with a sack of mail, / a bank robber, escaped from jail... " a bride, her groom, etc.) plus some hefty critters try to pull the kite down only to be taken aloft. "Can I hold it now? / ... / I'm old enough - / I know I am!" Sam asks each time another victim ascends. "No you're too small!" comes the refrain. "This kite needs someone bigger!"
Reynolds's fine black line limns strong, crisp shapes and his saturated watercolors make a wonderful foil for the improbable aerodynamics. Because the pictures never cross over into cartoonishness, the focus remains on the earthbound Sam and his determination to prove his mastery. Finally, when Sam is the only one not airborne, he grabs the string "and even though he wound and wound, / his feet stayed firmly on the ground." With everyone returned to terra firma, Emmett and Reynolds offer satisfaction to young readers on two counts - Sam not only gets his moment of triumph, he also gets to say, "told you so." Age 4-7.
PUBLISHER'S WEEKLY
Sam and his Dad have made a kite, but Dad is reluctant to let Sam fly it. His reason (or excuse?) is that young Sam is too small to manage it. The colourfully accomplished, energetic full- and double-page illustrations then proceed to follow the kite's journey skyward, pulling not only Dad but also an extravagantly grand and comic mass of people and animals - until inevitably, it is brought back to earth by young Sam. The entire narrative canters along in brisk, tidily rhythmic and neatly rhymed verse. Early years classrooms would be all the brighter for the presence of this book, not least because of the subtle way in which it encourages children to join in.
Trevor Dickinson, SCHOOL LIBRARIAN
PreSchool-Grade 1. When Sam and his father embark on a day of kite flying, the boy repeatedly asks to hold the string, but is told that he is too little. As the kite gathers strength, it carries off first his father and then many unsuspecting people who happen to be in its path-including a bank robber, a bride and groom, a postman, and a policeman on a horse. Sam is told by all in a repeated refrain: "No, you're too small / - This kite needs someone bigger." Finally, the child proves his worth by seizing the string and winding the kite and all of the hangers-on to safety. Reynolds's colorful watercolor cartoons depict the bouncy adventure, which is told in singsong verses. Sam sums it up with, "I'm not too small, and as you see, / this kite needs someone JUST LIKE ME!" Young readers will appreciate the boy's predicament and love the fact that, despite his small stature, he saves the day. A great choice for storytime and one-on-one sharing.
G. Alyssa Parkinson, SCHOOL LIBRARY JOURNAL
Sam and Dad make a kite and take it out to fly on a windy day. Sam is not allowed to hold the kite string because this job requires 'someone bigger', but then the wind blows so hard that Dad is lifted up into the sky. From then on everyone joins in trying to pull the kite down with amusing results! With its rhyming text and repetition, this is a delightful story about the frustrations of being a small child.
BOOKTRUST
This is a delightful tale of lyrical text and fanciful pictures as Sam and his dad have adventures with the kite they have made. They chose a windy day to try it out. Sam wants to try it out first but his dad tells him he is too little. While Sam is wishing he were bigger, his dad launches the kite into the sky. It pulls Sam's dad higher and higher until he is above the town and people everywhere try to pull him down. The postman, bank robber and policeman all try to help, but they are pulled up too. Firemen, a rhino and other animals from the zoo are pulled up as Sam runs after his dad, wanting to hold the kite. Sam saves the day by grabbing hold of the kite and he is able to keep his feet on the ground as everyone comes back down to earth. A fun story for readers proving that bigger doesn't always mean better.
Michele Wilbur, CHILDREN'S LITERATURE
PreS-Gr. 1. Sam and his dad take their homemade kite out on a windy day to give it a try. Sam pleads with Dad to let him hold it, but Dad says, "No, you're too small! This kite needs someone bigger." Then, as Sam watches, Dad is pulled into the sky. A postman, a bank robber, a policeman riding on a horse, a bridegroom ("and his bride, of course") try to pull the kite down, but are swooped up right along with Dad. At every turn, Sam's efforts to help are met with the refrain, "This kite needs someone bigger." Reynolds takes full advantage of the slapstick nature of the story, matching the silliness with humorous watercolor scenes, often shown from unusual aerial perspectives, depicting astonished people on the ground watching as a growing parade of humans and animals dangle from the kite string. Of course, Sam proves in the end that he is big enough to handle the kite, and kids will cheer his heroics. The catchy rhymes and colorful art make this a good choice for a spring storytime.
Lauren Peterson, BOOKLIST
When a kite whisks Sam's father, a bevy of townspeople, and even some zoo animals into the air, only small Sam can keep his feet on the ground and reel them all in. Clever rhymes and a bouncy rhythm enhance the comically cumulative scenario, while bold watercolors add dramatic perspectives and expressive characterizations.
THE HORN BOOK GUIDE
Grades Pre-1: The Big Enormous Turnip becomes a kite in this story of Sam and Dad who try to fly their homemade kite. Dad says Sam is too small, someone bigger is needed as he is pulled into the air. Many more join him from firemen to zoo animals, before Sam actually grabs hold of the kite with feet planted on the ground and reels them in. Neither the rhyme nor the sequencing strays in this delightful cumulative tale. The bright primary color illustrations spread over the page and from various angles capture the topsy turvy action.
Bayviews Rating: OUTSTANDING
Sherrill Kumler, Hayward PL, BAYVIEWS
For sheer fun for the little ones, Someone Bigger by Jonathan Emmett and Adrian Reynolds would be hard to beat - a tale of how you don't need to be big to be big.
A lively picture book, it all centres around a kite which carries everyone and everything off until little Sam takes matters in hand and shows the world that yes, he most definitely is big enough to take charge.
Phil Hewitt, WEST SUSSEX GAZETTE
A cautionary tale warning all bossy dads that they are not always right! Sam and his father are flying their kite, but Dad thinks Sam is too small to fly it properly. Boy, was he wrong! Great for getting kids to really laugh - both at Sam and his unfortunate dad, and also at themselves and their daddy.
Fabulously drawn pictures make this book really popular with little boys, who want to BE Sam!
PARENTS AND KIDS
