Tripping the Science-Fantastic
By THEODORE STURGEON
[part of article omitted]
Reading a Hugh Walters novel fills this old hand with a poignant nostalgia. Not only Jules Verne, but the early "Amazing Stories" treated us, when we were children, with didactic tales of real scientific fact overlaid with adventure as their sugar-coating. Walters's FIRST CON- TACT? (Nelson, $5.95) is just such a tale, its plot dealing with the prim- itive Us encountering the cultivated Them, but carrying a heavy cargo of fact and logical extrapolation as its raison d'être. No kid who reads this can possibly come out of it with- out knowing more than what he went in with. It may not do as much for understanding the human condition, but then that is not what such a book is for. |
The New York Times Book Review,
24th February, 1974
|
|
FIRST CONTACT? by Hugh Walters. Thomas Nelson, 1973. 174 p. $5.95. Age level: 10-13
Radio signals have been received from the vicinity of Uranus and two ships, each with
a crew of four, are sent to investigate. All are hoping for first contact with an alien
intelligence, all despite their prior experience in space admit to some fear of the unknown.
The signal is traced to one of Uranus' moons, and it is there that the two ships land and all
but two of the crew enter the alien vessel to converse with the visitor. Those two remaining
behind do not believe in the alien's benvolence, just the opposite, and decide to take
action. Tragedy is averted by the alien's advanced technology. The conflict between man's
intellectual ability and his animal instincts which make him react with fear and violence to
new situations is strongly demonstrated.
Mr. Walters is able to put across science and technology in an easily grasped manner;
the flight, landings, control center on Earth are all very realistic. Yet he just as competently
presents questions of the highest philosophical and personal concern in a manner that all can
understand. Aimed at the teenage/young adult reader, the novel teaches while it entertains,
presenting questions of destiny and religion without cant or dogma. -Gail C. Futoran
|
Leinz, November 1974
|