AUTOMATIC COMPUTER TRANSLATION Clifford Miller
 Tel: +44 (0) 20  8663 0044                                               Fax: +44 (0) 20 8663 0011
Burnhill Business Centre 50 Burnhill Road Beckenham Kent BR3 3LA England

E-mail Clifford Miller

Return to: Vaccine Damage.
AUTOMATIC COMPUTER TRANSLATION
日 本 語 - 機械翻訳 


Vaccines Did Not Save Us - 2 Centuries of Official Statistics

Here 2 centuries of UK, USA and Australian official death statistics show conclusively and scientifically modern medicine is not responsible and played little part in substantially improved life expectancy and survival from disease in western economies.

The Measles mortality graphs are enlightening and contradict the claims of Government health officials that vaccines have saved millions of lives.  It is a plainly unscientific claim which the data show is untrue.
[larger graphs below]


The success of the City of Leicester, England was remarkable in reducing smallpox mortality substantially compared to the rest of England and other countries by abandoning vaccination between 1882 and 1908 [see more below].

Scurvy Mortality Rates

To start you with something simple, Scurvy, Typhoid and Scarlet Fever are good examples to use as comparisons with “vaccinatable” diseases.

The main advances in combating disease over 200 years have been better food and clean drinking water.  Improved sanitation, less overcrowded and better living conditions also contribute.

UK Scurvy Mortality Rates 1901 to 1967uk-scurvy-1901-1967

UK Scurvy Mortality Rates 1901 to 1967 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com

Medicine and especially drugs and vaccines played no part in the fall in Scurvy death rates and the same can be seen for other diseases. Scurvy is a condition caused by a lack of vitamin C. Poor nutrition, particularly a lack of fresh fruit and vegetables, can result in Scurvy.  Mortality rates fell dramatically as living conditions improved.


TYPHOID & SCARLET FEVER

MORTALITY RATES UK, USA & AUSTRALIA

Typhoid and Scarlet Fever vanished without vaccines but with clean water, better nutrition, sanitation and living conditions.

USA Compared to UK Typhoid Mortality 1901 to 1965us-uk-typhoid-1901-1965

USA Compared to UK Typhoid Mortality 1901 to 1965 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com
___________________________________________________________

USA Compared to UK Scarlet Fever Mortality 1901 to 1965us-uk-scarlet-1901-1965

USA Compared to UK Scarlet Fever Mortality 1901 to 1965 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com
________________________________________________________

Australia Typhoid Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970Australia Typhoid Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970

Australia Typhoid Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970 - [SOURCE: Data - Official Year Books of the Commonwealth of Australia, as reproduced in Greg Beattie's book "Vaccination A Parent's Dilemma"]

______________________________________________________________
Australia Scarlet Fever Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970

Australia Diphtheria Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970

Australia Scarlet Fever Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970 - [SOURCE: Data - Official Year Books of the Commonwealth of Australia, as reproduced in Greg Beattie's book "Vaccination A Parent's Dilemma"]

MEASLES MORTALITY UK & USA

By 2007 the chance of anyone in England and Wales dying of measles if no one were vaccinated was less than 1 in 55 million. The chance of being struck by lightning is 30 to 60 times higher: Tornado & Storm Research Organisation
Measles Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999

Measles Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999

Measles Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999 - Logarithmic Scale [By Clifford G. Miller - For Evidence in the Dr Jayne Donegan General Medical Council Hearings August 2007, Manchester, England

Note that what seem large fluctuations after MMR vaccination was introduced in 1988 are not so large and are a feature of plotting the graph on a logarthmic scale.  This can be seen in the following graph,  plotted on an analogue scale.
Measles Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999

Measles Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999 - Analog Scale

Measles Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999 - Analog Scale - [By Clifford G. Miller - For Evidence in the Dr Jayne Donegan General Medical Council Hearings August 2007, Manchester, England]

The graph below is from a peer refereed medical paper: Englehandt SF, Halsey NA, Eddins DL, Hinman AR. Measles mortality in the United States 1971-1975. Am J Public Health 1980;70:1166–1169.  The red dotted trendline has been added.  This shows US measles mortality was falling regardless of whether vaccination was used.  By 2010 overall measles mortality in the USA was to fall to around 1 in 25 million without vaccines. As the severity of measles declined, long term complications would also. Whilst people still caught measles it was not the dreaded disease we are told it is today.

USA Measles Mortality 1912 to 1975measlesmortalityusa1971-75_1

USA Measles Mortality 1912 to 1975 [Source: Measles mortality in the United States 1971-1975. Halsey et al, Am J Public Health 1980;70:1166–1169.

The seeming fall in reported cases in the above Halsey graph after 1968 is misleading. Doctors are poor in accuracy of diagnosis and follow fashions.  Official UK records for 2006 show that when doctors are looking for a disease, they overdiagnose suspected measles cases by ten times higher than are confirmed by laboratory testing [CDR Weekly, PHLS 12:26].

Correspondingly, when vaccination was introduced, they will tend to follow the fashion of not diagnosing measles, where they believe it controlled by vaccination. This following of fashions has been seen in other areas, including Coroner diagnoses of causes of death.
USA Measles Mortality Compared to UK 1901 to 1965

us-uk-measles-1901-1965

USA Measles Mortality Compared to UK 1901 to 1965 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com
__________________________________________________________
Australia Measles Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970

Australia Measles Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970

Australia Measles Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970 - [SOURCE: Data - Official Year Books of the Commonwealth of Australia, as reproduced in Greg Beattie's book "Vaccination A Parent's Dilemma"]

MORTALITY, LIFE EXPECTANCY, HEALTHCARE COSTS UK, USA AND WORLDWIDE

Does paying for healthcare bring you better health and a longer life?  No.  The following graphs show that in 1996, average life expectancy in the US was 18th of all countries, being 5 years less than Canada and behind the UK.  But Americans were paying per person US$1000 or over 1/3rd more than Canadians and nearly 2/3rds more than the British.  And if you then take a look at the graphs of mortality, what were Americans getting for their money?  Mortality rates were falling anyway, regardless and kept on falling.  Life expectancy increased as time went by, but again substantially due to overall improved living conditions?

World Life Expectancy by Country 1996

world-life-1996

World Life Expectancy by Country 1996 - Source: Statistical Abstract of the World - 3rd Edn 1997
____________________________________________
World Healthcare Costs ($) 1990- Source: Statistical Abstract of the World - 3rd Edn 1997
world-healthdollars-1990

World Healthcare Costs ($) 1990 - Source: Statistical Abstract of the World - 3rd Edn 1997- Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com
__________________________________________________________
USA Life Expectancy by Age 1900 to 1998

us-life-1900-1998

USA Life Expectancy by Age 1900 to 1998 - Sources: Historical Statistics of the United States - Colonial Times to 1970, Part 1. Bureau of the Census pp 12, 56. Vital Statistics of the United States 1980, 1990, 1992.  Statistical Abstract of the United States 2001, 121st Edn, Nov 2001 p74.
- Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com

MORTALITY RATES USA AND UK

USA Mortality by Age at Death 1900 to 1970
agemortality-1-1900-1970

USA Mortality by Age at Death 1900 to 1970 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com
___________________________________________________________

England & Wales Total Infant Mortality 1901 to 1999

England & Wales Total Infant Mortality 1901 to 1999

England & Wales Total Infant Mortality 1901 to 1999 [By Clifford G. Miller - For Evidence in the Dr Jayne Donegan General Medical Council Hearings August 2007, Manchester, England]

DISEASE MORTALITY RATES UK, USA & AUSTRALIA

MEASLES, SCARLET FEVER, WHOOPING COUGH, TYPHOID, DIPHTHERIA, INFLUENZA, PNEUMONIA & TUBERCULOSIS

The following is the same USA graph as just above, but with Influenza and Tuberculosis Deaths included.  And you can see that Influenza deaths were not prevented by a vaccine - because for most of the period covered, there was no vaccine available at all and when it became available, it was not freely available until the present day - when guess what - ‘flu mortality had already plummeted - and guess what else - it does not work particularly well either - in fact so badly it may well be best avoided.

USA Disease Mortality 1900 to 1965 Measles, Typhoid, Pertussis (Whooping Cough), Diphtheria, Scarlet Fever, Influenza & Pneumonia, Tuberculosis

us-flu-tb-2-1900-1965

USA Disease Mortality 1900 to 1965 Measles, Typhoid, Pertussis (Whooping Cough), Diphtheria, Scarlet Fever, Influenza & Pneumonia, Tuberculosis Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com
_______________________________________________________

The following is the same graph as above but showing the full curve for influenza and pneumonia mortality.

USA Disease Mortality 1900 to 1965 Measles, Typhoid, Pertussis (Whooping Cough), Diphtheria, Scarlet Fever, Influenza & Pneumonia, Tuberculosis - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com

________________________________________________
UK Disease Mortality 1901 to 1965 Measles, Typhoid, Pertussis (Whooping Cough), Diphtheria, Scarlet Fever

DIPHTHERIA MORTALITY RATES 

England, USA & Australia

Here we see Diphtheria mortality falling all by itself.  In the UK, although the vaccine was introduced in 1940, most children particularly under 5 did not get it  and there was a large catch-up campaign in 1945-6.  The under 5 age group are the most at risk from infectious disease.  But can you see any difference in the rate of fall of mortality from Diphtheria after 1946 in the UK?  No?  Surprised?

USA Compared to UK Diphtheria Mortality 1901 to 1965us-uk-diphtheria-1901-1965

USA Compared to UK Diphtheria Mortality 1901 to 1965 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com
____________________________________________________________
England & Wales Diphtheria Mortality 1901 to 1999

England & Wales Diphtheria Mortality 1901 to 1999

England & Wales Diphtheria Mortality 1901 to 1999 - [By Clifford G. Miller - For Evidence in the Dr Jayne Donegan General Medical Council Hearings August 2007, Manchester, England
____________________________________________________________

Australia Diphtheria Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970Australia Diphtheria Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970
Australia Diphtheria Mortality Rates 1880 to 1970 - [SOURCE: Data - Official Year Books of the Commonwealth of Australia, as reproduced in Greg Beattie's book "Vaccination A Parent's Dilemma"]

WHOOPING COUGH (PERTUSSIS) MORTALITY RATES

UK, USA & Australia

Whooping Cough or Pertussis - again, the mortality rates fell substantially well before any vaccines were introduced.  The contribution, if any, to overall health has been neglible.


us-uk-pertussis-1901-1965

USA Compared to UK Whooping Couch (Pertussis) Mortality 1901 to 1965 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com

uk-pertussis-1838-1978

UK Whooping Couch (Pertussis) Mortality 1838 to 1978 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com

“]England & Wales Whooping Cough (Pertussis) Mortality 1901 to 1999

England & Wales Whooping Cough (Pertussis) Mortality 1901 to 1999 [By Clifford G. Miller - For Evidence in the Dr Jayne Donegan General Medical Council Hearings August 2007, Manchester, England

Mumps Mortality

England & Wales

“]Mumps Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999

Mumps Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999 [By Clifford G. Miller - For Evidence in the Dr Jayne Donegan General Medical Council Hearings August 2007, Manchester, England

[caption id="" align="aligncenter" width="450" caption="Australian Whooping Cough (Pertussis) Mortality 1880-1970 - [SOURCE: Data - Official Year Books of the Commonwealth of Australia, as reproduced in Greg Beattie's book "Vaccination A Parent's Dilemma""]Australian Whooping Cough (Pertussis) Mortality 1880-1970[/caption]

[SOURCE: Data - Official Year Books of the Commonwealth of Australia, as reproduced in Greg Beattie's book "Vaccination A Parent's Dilemma"]

Tetanus Mortality

England & Wales 1901 to 1999

“]Tetanus Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999

Tetanus Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999 [By Clifford G. Miller - For Evidence in the Dr Jayne Donegan General Medical Council Hearings August 2007, Manchester, England

Tetanus Mortality England & Wales 1901 to 1999

SMALLPOX MORTALITY

UK, USA & SWEDEN

In the graphs notice the large numbers of deaths caused by the smallpox vaccine itself.  By 1901 in the UK, more people died from the smallpox vaccination than from smallpox itself.  The severity of the disease dimished with improved living standards and was not vanquished by vaccination, as the medical “consensus” view tells us. Any vaccine which takes 100 years to “work” is not.  On any scientific analysis of the history and data, crediting smallpox vaccine for the decline in smallpox appears misplaced.

When during 1880-1908 the City of Leicester in England stopped vaccination compared to the rest of the UK and elsewhere, its survival rates soared and smallpox death rates plummetted [see table below].  Leicester’s approach also cost far less.

uk-vacc-deaths-1875-1922

UK Deaths Caused by Smallpox Vaccination 1875 to 1922 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com

uk-vacc-deaths-1906-1922

UK Deaths from Smallpox Vaccine Compared To Smallpox Mortality 1906 to 1922 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com

Extracts from “LEICESTER: Sanitation versus Vaccination” By J.T. Biggs J.P.

For more details see:LEICESTER AND SMALL-POX

SMALLPOX FATALITY RATES, percent, of cases, in vaccinated and re-vaccinated populations compared with “unprotected” Leicester, in varying periods from 1860 to 1908.

TABLE 21.

Name.

Period.

Small-Pox.  Cases

Small-Pox. Deaths.

Fatality-rate per cent. of Cases

Japan

1886-1908

288,779

77,415

26.8

British Army (United Kingdom)

1860-1908

1,355

96

7.1

British Army (India)

1860-1908

2,753

307

11.1

British Army (Colonies)

1860-1908

934

82

8.8

Royal Navy

1860-1908

2,909

234

8.0

Grand Totals and case fatality rate per cent, over all


296,730

78,134

26.3

Leicester (since giving up vaccination)

1880-1908

1,206

61

5.1

Biggs saidIn this comparison, I have given the numbers of revaccinated cases, and deaths, and each fatality-rate separately and together, so that they may be compared either way with Leicester. In pro-vaccinist language, may I ask, if the excessive small-pox fatality of Japan, of the British Army, and of the Royal Navy, are not due to vaccination and revaccination, to what are they due? It would afford an interesting psychical study were we able to know to what heights of eloquent glorification Sir George Buchanan would have soared with a corresponding result—but on the opposite side.

TABLE 29.
Small-Pox Epidemics, Cost, and Fatality Rates Compared.


Vaccinal Condition

Small-Pox Cases

Small-Pox Deaths

Fatality-rate Per Cent

Cost of Epidemic

London 1900-02

Well Vaccinated

9,659

1,594

16.50

£492,000

Glasgow 1900-02

Well Vaccinated

3,417

377

11.03

£ 150,000

Sheffield 1887-88

Well Vaccinated

7,066

688

9.73

£32,257

Leicester 1892-94

Practically Unvaccinated

393

21

5.34

£2,888

Leicester 1902-04 Practically Unvaccinated 731 30 4.10 £1,602
City of Leicester Smallpox Deaths 1880-1908

City of Leicester Smallpox Deaths 1880-1908


uk-smallpox-1838-1890

UK Smallpox Mortality Rates Compared to Scarlet Fever 1838 to 1890 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com
sweden-smallpox-1821-1852

Sweden Smallpox Mortality Rates 1821 to 1852 - Published: Roman Bystrianyk, healthsentinel.com

Return to main page.

Tel: +44 (0) 20  8663 0044                                               Fax: +44 (0) 20 8663 0011
Burnhill Business Centre 50 Burnhill Road Beckenham Kent BR3 3LA England
E-mail Clifford Miller